SAN DIEGO –– SeaWorld said yesterday it planned to replace its signature Shamu killer whale shows in San Diego with displays focused on “conservation”, after grappling with sagging attendance and years of criticism over treatment of the captive marine mammals.
Animal rights activists, pressing to end public exhibition of killer whales altogether, branded the SeaWorld announcement as little more than window dressing designed to make continued display of the animals more palatable to the public.
The move, unveiled in a company presentation to investors, followed a vote by California regulators last month barring SeaWorld San Diego from continuing to breed the killer whales, or orcas, if it proceeds with a planned expansion of their artificial habitat.
SeaWorld Entertainment Inc. chief executive officer Joel Manby said 2016 would be the last year of the park’s “current orca experience”, which features the black and white marine predators performing various tricks at the direction of trainers.
A highlight of those shows has been a leaping orca unleashing an enormous splash on to the front rows of spectators seated in the park’s outdoor Shamu Stadium arena, named for the original killer whale star of SeaWorld’s performances in the 1960s and early 1970s.
“In 2017 we’re going to launch an all-new orca experience with a conservation theme in a more natural setting,” Manby said, adding that plans were based on SeaWorld guests surveys.
“They want the San Diego whale experience to be what the animal would do in the wild,” he said in response to questions. “They jump in the wild, they splash in the wild.”
He did not elaborate, saying only that there would be fewer theatrics. But a company Press release said the attraction would focus on the animals’ natural behaviours.
“The show will include conservation messaging and tips guests can take home to make a difference for orcas in the wild,” it said.
There was no mention of any changes in the works for orca attractions at the company’s two other American aquatic theme parks, in Orlando, Florida, and San Antonio, Texas.
Investors calling into the company’s presentation did not ask about the possible financial implications of the change. But the announcement came on the heels of lackluster third-quarter earnings at SeaWorld, and its shares closed down $0.23, or 1.26 percent, on the New York Stock Exchange at $17.91.
SeaWorld has faced heated criticism and declining revenues since the release of the 2013 documentary film Blackfish, which depicted the captivity and public exhibition of killer whales as inherently cruel.
The film, which SeaWorld has criticized as inaccurate and misleading, also explored the circumstances leading to the 2010 death of a top SeaWorld trainer, who was pulled underwater and drowned by an orca she had performed with in Florida.
Trainers have not been allowed back into the water with killer whales during SeaWorld performances since that incident.
The company has sought to counter negative publicity surrounding Blackfish with a public relations blitz aimed at drawing attention to SeaWorld’s role in marine mammal research and its rescue and rehabilitation of animals in the wild.
A plan by the San Diego park to enlarge its seven-million-gallon orca pool complex as part of a $100 million Blue World expansion drew opposition from animal rights groups and their supporters, who want to see the park’s collection of 11 killer whales released into coastal sanctuaries instead.
The state Coastal Commission voted unanimously in October to permit the expansion, but only on condition that captive breeding of the whales ceased, along with the transfer or sale of new whales to the park.
The company, which has said it would challenge the commission’s ruling, gave no indication yesterday that it was ready to give up its orca breeding programme.
SeaWorld’s critics said the newly announced display plans were designed to appease a growing segment of the public that has come to regard orca shows as inhumane exploitation of intelligent creatures.
“An end to SeaWorld’s tawdry and circus-style performance is inevitable, but it’s actually captivity that denies these far-ranging orca the opportunity to engage in behaviours that are natural and important to them,” said Ben Williamson, director of People for the Ethical Treatment Of Animals (PETA).