Delicate balance between progress and preservation

The government’s decision to proceed with the $176 million hotel development at the Holetown Civic Centre, despite significant public opposition, has left many raising questions about the balance between economic development and community preservation. While the promise of increased tourism and foreign exchange is undoubtedly appealing, the cost to the heart of life in Holetown cannot be ignored.

The insistence by Senior Minister Dr William Duguid on the adequacy of public consultation about the controversial project will not sit well with residents and other stakeholders.

In a ministerial statement last Friday, he told Parliament, “There has been no attempt to hide anything. We have been speaking about this at public meetings, publishing notices, and discussing it in Parliament. The facts are on the record.

“This project has been in the works for years, and we are committed to moving forward in a way that benefits the people of Barbados.”

However, many will rightfully argue that meetings and notices do not equate to genuine dialogue and consideration of the public’s concerns. The relocation of the civic centre, a space that has served generations in St James and beyond, represents a significant disruption. While a new facility is promised, the loss of the historic site, anchored by the 1905 monument, is a blow to the area’s cultural identity.

We note the decision to award the contract to ICBL over a competing condominium proposal, based on the perceived economic benefits of a hotel.

According to the Senior Minister: “A hotel development offers greater value-added. It will generate employment, bring in foreign currency, and boost tourism in the area.”

There is no denying that tourism is vital to Barbados, but it should not come at the expense of community well-being.

There are also lingering concerns about the potential for increased traffic congestion, infrastructure challenges and the impact on the historical fabric of Holetown that must be thoroughly addressed, not merely acknowledged with promises of future plans.

The government’s assurances regarding the protection of the national monument are welcome but will do little to alleviate the broader concerns about the project’s impact as expressed by The Barbados National Trust, the Congress of Trade Unions and Staff Associations of Barbados (CTUSAB), and numerous others that have all voiced legitimate concerns. 

It is important to acknowledge that economic development and community preservation are not mutually exclusive. A more balanced approach is needed—one that prioritises genuine public consultation and considers the long-term impact on the community. The government must demonstrate that it is truly listening to the concerns of residents and stakeholders and that it is committed to finding solutions that benefit all Barbadians.

Tourism is undeniably a cornerstone of Barbados’ economy. It generates employment, drives investment, and provides the resources necessary for national development. However, unchecked tourism development can erode the qualities that make Barbados unique. The allure of pristine beaches and warm hospitality is linked to the island’s people, historical sites, cultural traditions, and the authentic experiences they offer.

Preserving local heritage spaces is not merely about preserving old buildings or artifacts. It’s about safeguarding the stories, traditions, and values that have shaped Barbadian society. These spaces provide invaluable insights into our past and serve as a vital link between generations.

We also know that increasingly, tourists are seeking authentic experiences. Further, heritage tourism can be a powerful economic driver, attracting visitors interested in cultural experiences and generating revenue for local businesses.

At this stage, Barbadians will have to come to terms with the project. But we hope that the government, as it seeks to balance the country’s needs, will formulate a comprehensive national plan to guide tourism development, ensuring that it aligns with the preservation of cultural and natural heritage.